Skip to main content

Book Review: The Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities by John Mearsheimer


The Great Delusion: Liberal Dreams and International Realities by John Mearsheimer challenges progressive liberalism to its core.  Through his most recent book, Mearsheimer argues that progressivism is the root problem in the United States foreign policymaking.  The ideology encourages a messianic state to spread its values across the world or to remake the world in its image.  This ideology is the foundation of what is known as liberal hegemony, which Mearsheimer and other realist international relations scholars claim has resulted in instability throughout the world and is destined to fail.  He argues that realism and nationalism will overcome liberalism because liberalism does not take into consideration how the world actually operates thus it lends itself to foreign policy failures which the US has experienced since the end of the Cold War.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What to Look for in 2019: The Race for the Periphery

The wish for a world not dominated by a single power is still a hope and a dream.  On the global scale, the United States is unmatched compared to its geopolitical rivals (Russia and China).  This does not mean that the US influence is not invulnerable.  Geopolitical Futures released its annual geopolitical forecast predicting that 2019 will see powers battling for influence along the periphery.  I agree with their assessment, especially when the trends in Central Europe are studied. 

Geopolitical analysts are starting to see a recreation of an East-Westdivide in Europe.  Post-socialist economies are still developing immensely, but there is dissatisfaction over the progress that has been made.  A 2018 poll by GLOBSEC found that 21% of Slovaks, 38% of Czechs, 42% of Poles, and 45% of Hungarians identify that their countries are part of the West.  
A significant number of Central Europeans believe they belong in the middle of the east and west.  Respondents say they want their countries t…

Nationhood and Social Cohesion

Ideas of closed and open borders have dominated topics on migration in the American context.  The debates focus on what immigration policies should be instead of focusing attention on what is occurring in the international system. Questions of western identity infuse themselves into the discussion.  Western societies are gripped by the conflict between differing conceptions of the nation and idealism. Populist anti-immigrant movements have risen across the Western world.  The skepticism of immigration has newfound prominence in Brexit, Swedish Democrats, National Front, Alternative for Germany, Freedom Party, and President Trump’s government shutdown over a border wall.  In Western Europe fears of a changing national identity has led to the increase of support for immigration restrictions. The rise of populist movements has created political chaos.  The United Kingdom held a popular vote to exit the European Union without a plan in place in case the electorate voted to leave.  Negotiati…

Book Review: The Dark Double: U.S. Media, Russia, and the Politics of Values